Tomorrow in class, you will compose a reflective essay that documents the process of researching, drafting, and revising your bibliogrpahy and preface. In your reflection, you will include one quotation (see the directions below for details), which you will introduce with a signal phrase and follow with a parenthetical citation. Following your reflection, you will include a work cited entry.
To comply with the requirements for your reflection, you will need to complete the planning exercise that follows. In class, you will not be permitted to refer to this blog post or any other online resources. You will need to have all the necessary information written longhand in your journal.
Directions
Review the print sources included in your bibliography, and identify a detail that you learned about your subject. The source should not be your starting-point article or story, or your peer interview. Instead it should be one of the three sources that you located as part of your independent research.
Once you have identified that detail, draft in your journal a passage for your reflection that quotes the detail you learned, introduces the quote with a signal phrase, and follows it with a parenthetical citation.
If you do not have a physical copy of the complete MLA-style work cited entry for the source, compose one in your journal. In class, you will not be permitted to refer to any other online resources. You will need to have all the necessary information written longhand in your journal.
Sample Reflection Passage with Quotation
The similarity between the predicaments of the Neuroblast digients and the wildlife in Ted Chiang’s novella became clearer to me as I continued to read, and I was gaining a sense of the holistic approach that distinguished his fiction. Yet reading Stina Attebery’s study introduced me to another connection, one I had not considered. Although in my own reading I had grown aware of the parallels between the vanishing worlds of animals and software, Attebery’s article demonstrates how the humans in Chiang’s novella could follow a similar path to obsolescence. In Attebery’s words, “[T]he novella portrays digital technologies as hypervulnerable to many of the same forces of exploitation that impact the lives of animals, children, and corporate employees” (par. 25).
The bulleted list below outlines the progression of the writing in the passage above.
What I learned on my own (“became clearer to me as I continued to read”)
My discovery of the detail in the source (“Attebery’s study introduced me to another connection”)
The quotation that includes the detail I learned (“In Attebery’s words, ‘[T]he novella . . .'”)
The quotation you include may be drawn from your preface (as mine above is), or from one of your annotations, or it may be one that doesn’t appear in your project.
Sample Work Cited Entry
Note that the entry above for Stina Attebery’s article includes the web address, or URL, but the name of a database does not precede it. That’s because the journal Trace is available as an open source on the web, which is the exception rather than the rule for scholarly sources. If the source you quote is one available through the HPU Libraries site, include the name of the database in italics.
Next Up
In tomorrow’s class, you will compose a reflective essay that documents the process of researching, drafting, and revising your bibliography and preface. Complete the planning exercise above to ensure that your reflection fulfills the assignment’s requirements. If you are still in the process of completing your essay on Wednesday, your reflection will address your work in progress. The due date for posting to Blackboard and WordPress is tomorrow, November 18 (before class); the hard deadline is Friday, November 20 (before class). Although you can submit your assignment without a late penalty until the hard deadline, you should aim post by the due date barring extenuating circumstances.
Also, time permitting, tomorrow in class, you will read and annotate a short article focusing on titles and what makes them effective. That article will be the subject of a journal exercise and a bonus assignment. Directions for the bonus will be included in upcoming class notes.
This morning, we will examine the final chapters of The Lifecycle of Software Objects. As a lead-in to our discussion of those chapters, you and two or three of your classmates will compose a short response to the conclusion of Ted Chiang’s novella, a minimum of two complete sentences, that (1) presents a plausible alternative ending, and (2) explains why Chiang may have chosen not to conclude the novella that way.
After we discuss your responses and the conclusion of The Lifecycle of Software Objects, we will examine my model preface and bibliography, which I will distribute in class. Lastly, we’ll consider ways to develop your research for later projects in upper-level classes and the theoretical frameworks those projects would require. You will have the remainder of the class period to devote to your own annotated bibliography and preface.
Along with my model annotated bibliography and preface, I will distribute copies of a handout on theoretiacl frameworks and a checklist for your bibliography and preface assignment. Screenshots of those handouts follow.
Next Up
In class on Wednesday, you will compose a reflective essay that documents the process of researching, drafting, and revising your annotated bibliogrpahy and preface. In your reflection, you will include one quotation, which you will introduce with a signal phrase and follow with a parenthetical citation. You will also include a complete MLA-style work cited entry for the source.
To comply with the requirements for your reflection assignment, you will need to complete the planning exercise in tomorrow’s class notes. In class, you will not be permitted to refer to my blog or any other online resources. You will need to have all the necessary information written longhand in your journal.
Previous class notes include three annotated bibliography entries I drafted as models for you. The class notes for October 29 feature the entry for my starting-point source, Ted Chiang’s novella The Lifecycle of Software Objects; and Tuesday’s class notes present drafts of my entries for two peer-reviewed articles. Today’s class notes includes drafts of my fourth and fifth entries: a student interview and a magazine profile.
Bowry, Skylar. Interview. Conducted by Jane Lucas. 6 Nov. 2026.
Skylar Bowry details first encountering Ted Chiang’s novella The Lifecycle of Software Objects as required reading in English 1103: Academic Research and Writing, a class in which the reading assignments differ significantly from those of her high school English courses. Although she had never read Chiang’s fiction before and wasn’t a fan of sci-fi, she notes, it “kept my attention and pulled me in, so I actually enjoyed it. It made me like that type of fiction.”
Bowry’s observations provide a first-person account of an undergraduate’s initial experience with Chiang’s fiction. Her recollections of high school English reveal that her classes focused on short works of nonfiction, mostly news articles. That emphasis reflects a shift in the secondary education English curriculum prompted by the release of the Common Core Standards in 2010, which stipulate that 70% of high school seniors’ reading should be nonfiction and only 30% should be literature.
Skylar Bowry is a freshman criminal justice major at High Point University, where she is enrolled in English 1103, section eight.
Joshua Rothman’s New Yorker profile of Ted Chiang combines his reflections on the author’s first collection, Stories of Your Life and Others (2002), and his novella, The Lifecycle of Software Objects (2010), which was published alone by Subterranean Press before it was included in the collection Exhalation: Stories (2019). To his observations on those works, Rothman adds excerpts from a series of interviews conducted with Chiang in late 2016 to coincide with the film release of Arrival, the adaptation of his story “The Story of Your Life.” Regarding The Lifecycle of Software Objects, Rothman notes Chiang’s assertion that the novella “grew . . . out of his intellectual skepticism about how artificial life is imagined in science fiction” (par. 10).
“Ted Chiang’s Soulful Science Fiction” offers Rothman’s insights into the quality of Chiang’s writing that sets him apart from his contemporaries. Rothman observes, “Chiang has been described as a writer of ‘humanist’ sci-fi; many readers feel that his stories are unusually moving and wonder, given their matter-of-fact tone, where their emotional power comes from” (par. 6). Rothman does not pinpoint the source of their emotional power, but the response he elicits from Chiang provides a sense of it: “‘[W]hat makes any human being a good, reliable worker? . . . . A hundred thousand hours of good parenting, of unpaid emotional labor. That’s the kind of investment on which the business world places no value; it’s an investment made by people who do it out of love’” (par. 10). The vital role of parenting at the heart of Chiang’s statement is also a key factor in both Sunyoung Ahn’s and Stina Attebery’s studies of his novella, and the humanism Rothberg notes is central to Ahn’s analysis.
Joshua Rothman is a staff writer for The New Yorker. He is the author of the magazine’s weekly column “Open Questions” and has taught at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government.
Bonus Assignment
The assignment that follows invites you to join the discussion forum conversation in Chapter Eight of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects (151-52), which I have reproduced verbatim in the comment section of today’s post. Since the forum is restricted to people who are caregivers or parents for the Neuroblast digients, your response should present the point of view of a person in that role.
Directions
Reread the comments posted by Helen Costas, Maria Zheng, Derek Brooks, and Ana Alvarado.
Compose a comment of one complete sentence or more that responds to one or more of the caregiver/parent comments previously posted. Address Helen, Maria, Derek, and/or Ana by first name.
Keep in mind that since the forum is restricted to people who are caregivers or parents for the Neuroblast digients, the response should present the point of view of a person in that role. Also, be mindful that the adult nature of the subject matter does not warrant off-color or obscene language. Any comments deemed inappropriate will not be approved and the students who submitted them will not receive credit for the assignment
Submit your comment: Click the title of the post, then scroll down to the bottom. There you will see the image of an airmail envelope with a box for your comment. Type your comment in the box and click Comment. Post your reply by 5:00 p.m. tomorrow, Friday, November 13. I will make the comments visible after the deadline.
If you are not comfortable joining the conversation, do not submit a comment. You will have at least one additional bonus assignment before the end of the semester.
Next Up
Wordplay Day! To prepare for class, revisit the Merriam-Webster Scrabble Word Finder page, and review your journal notes and the blog posts devoted to Scrabble tips.
Last Thursday’s class notes detailed how perusing the works cited list for the peer-reviewed article “The Everyday Life of Artificial Intelligence: The Humanism of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects,” by Sunyoung Ahn, led me to three potential sources, one of which I have decided to include in my bibliography as a second peer-reviewed source. You are required to include only one peer-reviewed article or chapter from a university press book, but you are welcome to include more than one.
Today’s class notes include drafts of my annotated bibliography entries for my two peer-reviewed sources: “Losing Data Earth: Technological Obsolescence and Extinction in The Lifecycle of Software Objects,” by Stina Attebery, and Sunyoung Ahn’s article, which led me to Atteberry’s.
Sunyoung Ahn cites French philosopher Henri Lefebvre’s The Critique of Everyday Life (1977), in which Lefebvre speculates “that in the not-too-distant future human cells will be created artificially (which is perfectly conceivable) and given consciousness” (qtd. in Ahn 73). From that premise, Lefebvre supposes that such artificial intelligence will experience the same struggles in everyday life that humans face. For Ahn, that philosophy of Lefebvre’s aligns with Ted Chiang’s depiction of his digients’ development and their relationships to the trainer Ana Alvarado and animator Derek Brooks, the humans who work with the digients at Blue Gamma and later become their caregivers. Ahn notes that such scenarios in science fiction are rare: Rather than turning to the trope of the cautionary dystopian tale, Chiang presents characters who “take responsibility for their own creation[s]” (88) and who, along with the digients, “stay useful and relevant by constantly modifying themselves” (87).
Ahn’s study delineates Chiang’s focus on the formative stage of artificial intelligence as a point of contrast to AI as it is widely imagined as “developed, perfected, and therefore culminant” (78). Ahn demonstrates the singular vision of The Lifecycle of Software Objects as a narrative in which “humans anthropomorphize the digients” (87) and the digients lead the humans to “think digitally” (87).
Sunyoung Ahn, an associate professor of English at Korea University in Seoul, is the author of “New Sincerity, New Worldliness: Post 9/11 Fiction of Don Delillo and David Foster Wallace.”
Source Details–What to Include
Note that the entry below for Stina Attebery’s article includes the web address, or URL, but the name of a database does not precede it. That’s because the journal Trace is available as an open source on the web, which is the exception rather than the rule for scholarly sources. In my entry for Sunyoung Ahn’s article, included above, JSTOR precedes the web address, or URL, because, Ahn’s article is included in the MLA International Bibliography, which is available through JSTOR on the HPU Libraries site.
Attebery, Stina. “Losing Data Earth: Technological Obsolescence and Extinction in The Lifecycle of Software Objects.” Trace: A Journal of Media, Writing, and Ecology, 17 April 2017, http://tracejournal.net/trace-issues/issue1/07-attebery.html.
Stina Attebery examines Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects as a narrative in which digital entities do not substitute for their dwindling counterparts in the wild but instead experience obsolescence that parallels the endangerment and extinction of biological animals. Attebery suggests that the Neuroblast digient Jax’s anxiety regarding his vanishing platform, Data Earth, indicates that digital life may be “hypervulnerable compared to the slow cycles of animal death found in extinction and climate change” (par. 4).
Attebery’s study elucidates how life forms whose genomes are written in code—both the digients in Chiang’s novella and real-world digital entities—are surprisingly similar to biological animals in terms of their risk for endangerment. In Attebery’s words, “[d]igital life forms can be easily replicated and transformed and are more vulnerable to shifts in the market” (par. 4). As Attebery explains, since Chiang’s Neuroblast digients’ Data Earth virtual environment is a casualty of corporate takeover, and they cannot run on the newer platform Real Space, they are deemed irrelevant, but those technological changes alone do not lead to their change in fortunes. Because they lack the task-oriented focus of the newer Sophonce digients, they are perceived as unmarketable and valueless.
Stina Attebery is a lecturer in interdisciplinary studies in liberal arts at Cal Poly (California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo). She is the author of “Coshaping Digital and Biological Animals: Companion Species Encounters and Biopower in the Videogames Pikmin and Pokémon.” She also serves as managing editor for the Eaton Journal of Archival Research in Science Fiction.
Page Numbers Versus Paragraph Numbers
The entry for Ahn’s article includes page numbers in parenthetical citations because JSTOR files are photographic images of physical pages of journals. Attebery’s entry includes paragraph numbers because Trace is an unpaginated online journal. Whether your parenthetical citations contain page numbers or paragraph numbers will depend on whether the article is paginated. Note that the page numbers that you see on a print-out of an online article, such as Page 1 of 11 in the lower right, is not the journal pagination but the printer’s numbering. In parenthetical citations, do not list those numbers as page numbers. List the paragraph numbers instead.
Next Up
On Wednesday, we will examine Chapter Eight of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects, and you will have additional time to devote to your research and writing.
The October 23 Scrabble post listed toponyms (place names and words derived from places) in the first half of the alphabet. Today’s post includes a list of toponyms in the second half. Studying these playable proper nouns–playable because they’re also common nouns–offers you additional opportunities to broaden your vocabulary and up your game.
oxford: a type of shoe, also known as a bal or balmoral
panama: a type of wide-brimmed hat
paris: a type of plant found in Europe and Asia that produces a lone, poisonous berry
roman: a romance written in meter
scot: an assessed tax
scotch: to put an end to; or to etch or scratch (as in hopscotch)
sherpa: a soft fabric used for linings
siamese: a water pipe providing a connection for two hoses
swiss: a sheer, cotton fabric
texas: a tall structure on a steamboat containing the pilothouse
toledo: a type of sword known for its fine craftsmanship, originally from Toledo
wale: to injure, to create welts on the skin
warsaw: a type of grouper fish
waterloo: a definitive defeat
zaire: a currency of Zaire
Unexpected Finds Follow-Up
Yesterday’s post detailed how perusing the works cited list for the peer-reviewed article “The Everyday Life of Artificial Intelligence: The Humanism of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects,” by Sunyoung Ahn, led me to three potential sources.
Future posts will likely included annotated bibliography entries for two or more of those. For now, I offer the first draft of my entry for Ahn’s article:
Sample Annotated Bibliography Entry
Ahn, Sunyoung. “The Everyday Life of Artificial Intelligence: The Humanism of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects.” Science Fiction Studies, vol. 47, no. 1, Mar. 2020, pp. 73–92. EBSCOhost, https://doi.org/10.5621/sciefictstud.47.1.0073.
In Sunyoung Ahn’s “The Everyday Life of Artificial Intelligence: The Humanism of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects,” Ahn cites French philosopher Henri Lefebvre’s The Critique of Everyday Life (1977), in which Lefebvre speculates “that in the not-too-distant future human cells will be created artificially (which is perfectly conceivable) and given consciousness” (qtd. in Ahn 73). From that premise, Lefebvre supposes that such artificial intelligence will face the same struggles in everyday life as humans. For Ahn, Lefebvre’s philosophy aligns with Ted Chiang’s depiction of his digients’ development and their relationships with the trainer Ana Alvarado and the animator Derek Brooks, the humans who work with the digients at Blue Gamma and later become their caregivers. Ahn notes that such scenarios in science fiction are rare. Rather than turning to the trope of the cautionary dystopian tale, Chiang presents characters who “take responsibility for their own creation[s]” (88) and who, along with the digients, “stay useful and relevant by constantly modifying themselves” (87).
Ahn’s study delineates Chiang’s focus on the formative stage of artificial intelligence as a point of contrast to AI as it is widely imagined as “developed, perfected, and therefore culminant” (78). Ahn demonstrates the singular vision of The Lifecycle of Software Objects as a narrative in which “humans anthropomorphize the digients” (87) and the digients lead the humans to “think digitally” (87).
Sunyoung Ahn, an associate professor of English at Korea University in Seoul, is the author of “New Sincerity, New Worldliness: Post 9/11 Fiction of Don Delillo and David Foster Wallace.”
Secondary Quotations
The summary paragraph of my annotation includes a secondary quotation, also known as a secondary citation or indirect citation, which is line from another source quoted by the author of the source I am annotating. Because I name the author, Henri Lefebvre, in the sentence, the paranthetical citation is (qtd. in Ahn 73), which denotes that his words are quoted by Ahn on page 73. If I had not named Lefebvre in the sentence, his last name would be included in the parenthetical citation: (Lefebvre, qtd. in Ahn 73).
If you are quoting a writer or speaker who is not the author of your source, be sure to present the words as a secondary quotation. Otherwise you will commit a factual error.
Next Up
Monday, we will examine Chapter Seven of Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects, and you will have additional time to work on your annotated bibliography and preface
When I explored the MLA International Bibliography, one of the databases in the HPU Libraries A-Z Database List, my search yielded the listing for the peer-reviewed article “The Everyday Life of Artificial Intelligence: Humanism in Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects” (in the screenshot above). That article will serve as one of my sources, but it also led me to additional sources, ones I did not find in my search of the MLA International Bibliography.
After I accessed the full text of the article, I scrolled down to the works cited list: the list of sources that the author, Sunyoung Ahn, cites in her study. In the screenshot below, you see that four of the first five sources focus on science and philosophy, not on Chiang’s novella specifically. However, the title of the second entry, Tina Attebery’s article, clarifies that her article is a study of The Lifecycle of Software Objects, one that isn’t listed in the MLA database.
Farther down the list of works cited (see the screenshot below), I discovered a source devoted to Ted Chiang’s science fiction, an essay published in The New Yorker, the same magazine that published one of your assigned readings for the course: Dan Rockmore‘s “Should the Classroom Be More Like the Gym?” Directly above that essay is another source from The New Yorker. The title doesn’t indicate that it’s devoted to Ted Chiang’s fiction, but a search of the HPU Libraries’ catalog revals that it’s an essay-review of The Lifecycle of Software Objects. New Yorker articles are available through the ProQuest database, but they do not show up in searches of the MLA International Database because The New Yorker is a mainstream magazine, not a scholarly journal.
Takeaways on Unexpected Finds
Once you have found a peer-reviewed article for your bibliography, peruse the list of works cited for possible additional sources.
You may not be familiar with the magazine, journal, or book publisher, but the source’s presence in a peer-reviewed article tells you that it’s already been vetted. Determining the validity of an article or book chapter’s citations is part of the peer review process.
If you question whether you should include the source in your bibliography, ask me, Lauren Ksa, Assistant Director and Head of Research and Instructional Services, or use the Ask an HPU Librarian chat feature on the HPU Libraries site. It will connect you with an HPU librarian, not a chatbot.
Quiz Follow-Up
Rather than listing the answers to the questions on Monday’s quiz, I have followed each question below with a note regarding where to find the answer. By finding the answers yourself, you will learn more than you would from simply reading the answers in a list.
Last Thursday’s class notes, a follow-up to our library instruction, includes my recommendation for your next step for your research project. What is that step? See the October 29 class notes.
Thursday’s class notes include a segment of a research project I wrote as a model for you. What is the segment (what part of the project is it), and what is its subject? See the October 29 class notes and the November 2 class handout.
Last Friday’s class notes include two lists of words. What are the topics of those two lists? Note that Scrabble is the subject, not the topic. The topic is something more specific. See the October 30 class notes.
How have the digients’ circumstances changed since Chapter Two? See Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software Objects,Chapter Three, 88; Chapter Four, 100-102; Chapter Five, 118-19; and others.
How have Ana Alvarado and Derek Brooks’s personal and professional lives changed since Chapter Two? See Chapter Three, 91; Chapter Four, 94, 95, 98,108; Chapter 5, 121; and others).
Your quiz also included a bonus opportunity. Possible answers for that bonus are found in the October 30 class notes.
Next Up
Wordplay Day! To prepare for class, revisit the Merriam-Webster Scrabble Word Finder page, and review your journal notes and the blog posts devoted to Scrabble tips.
As I noted in class, you do not need to focus on the subject of your October 21 group presentation. Your presentations were only one of the reasons you read Matt Richtel’s, Charlotte Hu’s, Allison Aubrey’s, and Ulrich Boser’s articles. Another reason you read them is for the starting points they provide for research. The fifth presentation, on the first chapter of The Lifecycle of Software Objects, offers another starting point and Isaac Asimov’s “Runaround,” Brian Aldiss‘s “Supertoys Last All Summer Long” offer two more.
If you haven’t already drafted a bibliographic entry for the reading above that serves as your starting point, that should be your next step. The required elements for each bibliographic entry are outlined in your assignment and listed below.
Annotated Bibliographic Entry: Required Elements
A complete MLA-style bibliographic entry for each source. Sample entries for the starting-point sources (listed above) are included on your assignment handout, in the assignment file on Blackboard, and in yesterday’s class notes. As a guide for formatting the entries for your other sources, see Citations by Format and Works Cited: A Quick Guide on the MLA Style Center site. You are welcome to use citation generators, but be aware of their limitations. Some generators will yield entries that lack required elements; others will be flawed by errors of punctuation and/or mechanics. If you use a generator, compare the results with the samples on MLA’s site and edit as needed. Also, if you use a citation generator, be sure to select MLA, not APA, Chicago, or another style.
A one-paragraph summary of the source.
A second paragraph of commentary that elucidates the usefulness of the source to you and others researching your subject. Would it serve as a point of comparison or contrast to another source? Would it support or challenge an idea presented in another source? Is it a secondary source that sheds light on the meaning of a primary source? The last question pertains primarily to bibliographies that focus on one of the writers studied in the course.
A third short paragraph that names the author, his or her profession or job title, and additional publications. Look back at the first paragraph of this post. If the author of your starting-point article has an embedded link in his or her name, the link is for the writer’s official website. On that site, there’s an about page where you can find information to include in your third paragraph. If the author does not maintain his or her own site, you can find the necessary information elsewhere. NPR’s staff pages include one devoted to Allison Aubrey, the Penguin/Random House site’s authors pages include one for Isaac Asimov, and Time magazine’s feature “The 100 Most Influential People in AI” includes a page on Ted Chiang.
As a model for you, I have composed the sample entry included below. If your own starting-point source is Ted Chiang’s The Lifecycle of Software objects, you will draft summary and commentary paragraphs that you will revise after you finish reading the novella. That said, you should avoid including any details that are spoilers. The summary and commentary paragraphs of mine that follow provide specifics, but they do not give away the ending.
Sample Annotated Bibliographic Entry
Chiang, Ted. “The Lifecycle of Software Objects.” Exhalation and Other Stories. 2019. Vintage, 2020. pp. 62-172.
Ted Chiang’s novella The Lifecycle of Software Objects chronicles twenty years in the lives of its protagonists, Ana Alvarado and Derek Brooks, two software firm employees who—because of shifting economic and environmental landscapes—devote their days to jobs that differ markedly from the careers they imagined for themselves. Ana, a zoologist by training, finds herself training digients, short for digital entities, at the start-up company Blue Gamma. Her coworker, animation artist Derek Brooks, designs avatars for the digients that comply with the company’s specifications rather than his own aesthetic preferences. Though initially Ana and Derek’s interactions with the digients are limited to the workplace, as the novella progresses and Blue Gamma folds, the digients enter their personal lives, with Ana and Derek taking on the roles of caregivers.
As a primary source for studies of Chiang’s writing, The Lifecycle of Software Objects presents a possible microcosm of his wider fictional world. In the opening pages of the novella, readers do not meet the one-dimensional characters typical of genre fiction but rather two true-to-life twentysomethings forced to pivot from their life plans. Juxtaposing The Lifecycle of Software Objects with other novellas and stories of Chiang’s enables readers to identify patterns in his fiction and determine whether the verisimilitude of Ana and Derek’s narrative is the exception or the rule.
Ted Chiang is the author of two short story collections: The Stories of Your Life and Others and Exhalation: Stories. He is the recipient of four Hugo Awards, four Nebula Awards, and the Pen/Malamud Award for Short Story Writing. His story “The Story of Your Life” is the basis for the Academy Award-winning film Arrival. In 2023, Time magazine named him to its list of One Hundred Most Influential People in A.I.
My sample annotated bibliographic entry above is 305 words long. If the draft of your first entry is of comparable length, you will have reached one-sixth of the 1,800 minimum word count for your research project.
If you determine you want to use the source you located in the library on Wednesday, compose the bibliographic entry for that source as soon as you can. Building your bibliography piecemeal, one source at a time, will make your project far more manageable.
Next Up
Wordplay Day! To prepare for class, revisit the Merriam-Webster Scrabble Word Finder page, and review your journal notes and the blog posts devoted to Scrabble tips.
As a starting point for your bibliography work, today’s class will focus on locating sources. We will meet on the lower level of Smith Library, where Lauren Ksa, Assistant Director and Head of Research and Instruction, will lead us through the steps of finding articles and books available through the HPU Libraries’ databases.
At the beginning of class, I will distribute copies of your annotated bibliography and preface assignment. An additional copy of the assignment follows.
Research Project: Annotated Bibliography and Preface
Overview
Your third and final major writing assignment is an annotated bibliography and a preface that introduces it. Your bibliography may focus on (1) one of the aspects of the course: blogging, limiting screen time, writing longhand, playing Scrabble, or (2) the writing of one of the science fiction authors we have studied.
An annotated bibliography is a list of sources on a subject that includes a summary of each source. Some bibliographies include additional information, such as commentary on the source and the authors’ credentials, which is the type of bibliography that you will compose.
A preface introduces a piece of writing and explains how it came to be. The preface for your annotated bibliography will offer a first-person account of your research process.
Directions for Researching
Time permitting, devote the remainder of today’s class to locating a potential source for your bibliography.
After class, continue your work on your own. One of the early steps in your process should be composing an annotated bibliographic entry for the course reading that serves as your starting point, the short story or article that led to your choice of study.
Use the HPU Libraries site, https://www.highpoint.edu/library/, and Google Scholar to locate a minimum of three additional reliable and relevant print sources. (One of the class readings and your peer interview are two of your five required sources.) At least one of the three must be a peer-reviewed article or a chapter in a book published by a university press.
In class next week: Conduct a personal interview with a classmate and compose an annotated bibliographic entry for the interview. Details TBA.
Note: Additional class periods over the course of the next two weeks will be devoted to writing and research, along with our study of The Lifecycle of Software Objects.
Directions for Drafting, Revising, and Submitting
Write a preface that (1) presents the subject of your bibliography, and (2) addresses your purpose for compiling it. In other words: What drives your research? What question do you seek to answer about your subject? Also, (3) what larger project might develop from your bibliography? Would it be a project for a course in psychology, science, education, or another discipline? What would serve as its theoretical framework? In other words, through what academic lens would you examine your subject? Address all five of your sources in your preface and quote at least two of them.
After you draft your preface, turn back to your bibliography. Review your commentaries and consider where you might mention one source as a point of comparison (or contrast) with another.
Revise your preface and your bibliography, using the checklist provided (to be distributed in class) as a guide.
Before class on the due date: Post a copy of your revision to Blackboard and to your WordPress blog. In your blog post, omit the first-page information included in your file submitted to Blackboard (your name, professor’s name, course and section, and date). Add to your blog post an image that documents some part of your writing process away from the screen, such as the draft of an annotation in your journal, your handwritten notes on a research worksheet, or a longhand draft of your preface. Also, add an embedded link to a relevant website.
Note: Even though your work for this assignment will take place primarily in front of the screen, your writing process still involves putting pen to paper, and photographic documentation of that on your blog is a requirement of the assignment.
Sample MLA-Style Bibliographic Entries
Every student’s bibliography will include one of the following articles or stories.MLA
Aldiss. Brian. “Supertoys in Other Seasons.” Supertoys Last All Summer Long and Other Stories of Future Time. St. Martin’s Griffin, 2001, pp. 23-35.
—. “Supertoys Last All Summer Long.” Supertoys Last All Summer Long and Other Stories of Future Time. St. Martin’s Griffin, 2001, pp. 1-11.
—. “Supertoys When Winter Comes.” Supertoys Last All Summer Long and Other Stories of Future Time. St. Martin’s Griffin, 2001, pp. 12-22.
Asimov, Isaac. “Runaround.” I, Robot. 1950. Doubleday, 1963, pp. 40-58.
Chiang, Ted. “The Lifecycle of Software Objects.” Exhalation and Other Stories. 2019. Vintage, 2020. pp. 62-172.
Hu, Charlotte. “Why Writing by Hand is Better for Memory and Learning.” Ed. Lauren J. Young. Scientific American, 21 Feb. 2024. https://www.scientificamerican.com/ article /why-writing-by-hand-is-better-for-memory-and-learning/.
Note that the bibliographic entries in the Microsoft Word file or PDF that you submit to Blackboard will have hanging indents, unlike the block-style samples above. The first line of each entry will be flush left, and any subsequent lines will be indented five spaces or one-half inch.
Grade Criteria
An A research project includes all the following elements:
A preface of three or more paragraphs that (1) presents the subject of your bibliography, and (2) addresses your purpose for compiling it. In other words: What drives your research? What question do you seek to answer about one of the subjects that you’ve studied in the course or about one aspect of the course? Also, (3) what larger project might develop from your bibliography, and what would serve as its theoretical framework? In other words, through what academic lens would you examine your subject?Complete bibliographic entries for a minimum of five reliable and relevant sources, four of which are print, alphabetized by the writers’ last names.
A one-paragraph summary of each source followed by a paragraph of commentary and a third paragraph that presents the writer’s credentials.
A minimum of 1,800 words, total (preface and annotated bibliography combined).
An A research project complies with the requirements above and is also cohesive and relatively free of surface errors and contains no factual errors.
A B research project effectively meets all the requirements above but may be flawed by minor issues of organization and/or surface errors but contains no factual errors.
A C research project meets most but not all the requirements above and may also be flawed by issues of organization, surface errors, and/or factual errors.
A D research project meets only a few of the requirements above and may also be flawed by issues of organization, surface errors, and/or factual errors.
An F research project fails to meet the requirements above and may also be flawed by substantial issues of organization, surface errors, and/or factual errors.
Next Up
Wordplay Day! To prepare for class, revisit the Merriam-Webster Scrabble Word Finder page, and review your journal notes and the blog posts devoted to Scrabble tips.
As you revise your essay and your bibliographic entries, read “Strategy 1: Make Your Sources Speak” (328-29) and “Integrating Quotations into Your Paper” (343-46) in Writing Analytically. After you have read those sections of the textbook, ask yourself whether your reasons for the quotations you have included are clear to the reader. If your reasons aren’t clear, revise the passages that precede and follow each quotation to ensure that your source’s words are an integral part of your writing, rather than a seemingly random insertion.
You are required to quote only two of your sources in your essay, but you are welcome to include additional quotations in your essay and your annotations. Remember that you should avoid the word quotations in your project. We do not write and speak in quotations; we write and speak in words, phrases, and sentences.
Note how the lines that precede the quotations in the passage below introduce the quotations and how the lines that follow the quotations demonstrate their significance.
Take, for instance, the first and last words of the opening line of Junod’s Rogers’ profile, “Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?”: “Once upon a time, a little boy loved a stuffed animal whose name was Old Rabbit” (par. 1). Once upon a time, a staple of bedtime stories, recurs five times (pars. 6, 15, 21, 34, and 45). That repetition not only emphasizes the children’s world that the subject inhabits—as the host of the long-running Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood—but also connects the once-upon-a-time anecdotes of Rogers’ life with those of some of the viewers whose lives have been profoundly affected by his television show, and by him. A case in point: The first once-upon-a-time sentence ends with “Old Rabbit” (par. 1). Because readers know from the article’s headnote that the subject is Fred Rogers, they assume that the opening anecdote about a young boy who throws his stuffed rabbit out of the car window is Rogers himself, but later—a quarter of the way through the article—readers learn that the little boy is actually Junod, who uses the once-upon-a-time trope to link his story, and others’, to Rogers.’
The complete model essay and bibliography on Tom Junod’s writing, from which the passage above is drawn, is included at the end of this post.
Indirect Sources/Secondary Quotations
If you are quoting someone quoted by the author of a source, do not incorrectly attribute the words to the author.
Journalist Bronwen Dickey, a visiting professor at Duke, observes in Tom Junod’s writing, “a recognition of people’s pain that you don’t have unless you’ve been through some extraordinary pain yourself” (qtd. in Hendrickson 29).
A journalist who teaches Tom Junod’s writing in her college classes observes in his writing, “a recognition of people’s pain that you don’t have unless you’ve been through some extraordinary pain yourself” (Dickey qtd. in Hendrickson 29).
The two examples above demonstrate how to present an indirect source or secondary quotation. Qtd.in indicates that the speaker or writer of the words, Bronwen Dickey, is quoted on page twenty-nine of a source written by John Hendrickson. In the first example, Bronwen Dickey’s last name does not appear in the parenthetical citation because she is named in the sentence. In the second example, her last name is included in the parenthetical citation because she is not named in the sentence.
The same rules apply to indirect quotations in unpaginated sources:
Tom Junod writes of his subject’s desire to produce television programming for “the broadcasting of grace through the land” (Rogers qtd. in Junod, par. 32).
Tom Junod writes of Fred Rogers‘ desire to produce television programming for “the broadcasting of grace through the land” (qtd. in Junod, par. 32).
Note that in a parenthetical citation for an unpaginated source, a comma separates the author’s last name from the abbreviation par.
As one of the last steps in your revision process, consult the checklist I distributed in class. An additional copy is included below.
Checklist
Preparing for Your Reflection
In tomorrow’s class, you will compose a reflective essay focusing on the processes of researching, drafting, and revising your final essay and annotated bibliography. In your reflection, you will include a relevant quotation from Writing Analytically or from one of the sources included in your bibliography.
If you quote a line from “Integrating Quotations into Your Paper” or “Strategy 1: Make Your Sources Speak,” include a work cited entry for that section of the textbook at the end of your reflection. Write the work cited entry in the correct format in your journal, along with the line you will quote in your reflection for your reference.
Rosenwasser, David, and Jill Stephen. “Integrating Quotations into Your Paper.” Writing Analytically, 9th edition. Wadsworth/Cengage, 2024. pp. 343-36.
Rosenwasser, David, and Jill Stephen. “Strategy 1: Make Your Sources Speak.” Writing Analytically, 9th edition. Wadsworth/Cengage, 2024. pp. 328-29
You are welcome to quote another relevant section of Writing Analytically, but be sure to record the work cited entry in the correct format in your journal. Do the same if you plan to quote one of the sources in your annotated bibliography. During the writing of your reflection, which is a handwritten assignment, you will not have the option of referring to any parts of your essay and bibliography in electronic form. You may refer only to your journal, your textbook, your class handouts, and a physical copy of your essay and bibliography, if you opt to print one. You are not required to submit a paper copy of the assignment, but you are welcome to print one for your own reference.
Model Final Essay and Annotated Bibliography
I have included below the essay and bibliography on Tom Junod’s writing that I composed as a model for you. In my remarks about the project-in-progress in last Wednesday’s class, I mentioned that although the addition of a final essay of four hundred words (or slightly fewer) would fulfill the project’s 1,800-word minimum requirement, I would likely exceed the minimum to adequately chronicle my writing and research.
I far exceeded four hundred words, by roughly one thousand, making the complete project (essay and bibliography combined) about 2,800 words. If a 1,400-word final essay seems daunting as a model, look to my previous model, “Scrabble as a Game Changer in the College Classroom.” That essay and its bibliography are much shorter, a total of about 2,000 words, only three hundred more than the minimum word requirement. PDFs of both model essay and bibliography projects are posted in the sample papers folder on Blackboard.
“Writing by Ouija Board”: The Art of Tom Junod’s Prose
In late August 2003, the September issue of Esquire arrived at my house. The door of my town home had a mail slot—as many houses in Richmond’s Fan district do—so the magazine first appeared to me not in the confines of a mailbox but on the floor of the foyer amid a sea of catalogs and junk mail. I picked up the magazine with the intention of thumbing through it only briefly before placing it on the coffee table. But as I turned the pages, I glimpsed Richard Drew’s now-iconic 9/11 photograph of the unidentified Falling Man appearing to bisect the Twin Towers. I scanned the opening lines on the facing page—again with the intention of reading only briefly—but I was captivated by the first words: “In the picture, he departs from this earth like an arrow” (Junod, par. 1). I sat down and kept reading.
I didn’t stop until I’d read them all, all 7,334 words.
The next day, I walked into my freshman composition classes with copies of the opening paragraphs of “The Falling Man” in hand. Together, my students and I pored over Tom Junod’s words in what would become a yearly September ritual. Later, it became a twice-a-year ritual. For freshman writers, the value of examining those words extended beyond commemoration.
More than twenty years and two houses later, the current issue of Esquire arrived in the mailbox of my craftsman bungalow in High Point, North Carolina. As I thumbed through the pages, I was surprised to see the name, Tom Junod. It wasn’t a byline I saw; Junod had left Esquire in 2016 to join the staff of ESPN. Instead, his name appeared in the first lines of a profile by John Hendrickson, written on the occasion of the publication of Junod’s first book, his memoir, In the Days of My Youth I was Told What it Means to Be a Man—a title that alludes to Led Zeppelin’s “Good Times, Bad Times,” which opens with that line.
In my mind, I’d been turning over ideas for a bibliography project to complete as a model for my students. When I saw Hendrickson’s profile, I knew I’d found my subject.
Ever since “The Falling Man” first captured my attention, the pull of Junod’s prose has intrigued me. The renewed attention to his writing—prompted by the publication of his memoir—provided the impetus for a search for what specifically imbued his words with what seemed to be the proverbial je ne sais quoi, but in fact could be identified through careful study.
The starting point for my students’ research was a text they’d read for class—either by a writer we’ve studied or one that focuses on one of the aspects of the course (blogging, writing longhand, limiting screen time, playing Scrabble). For any student focusing on the writing of Tom Junod, “The Falling Man” was the starting point, so that’s where I began.
As I reread and marked up print-outs of “The Falling Man” and Junod’s Esquire profile of Fred Rogers, clear but complex patterns emerged. Repetition, which at first glance appeared solely for emphasis, was also a device linking images and ideas.
Take, for instance, the first and last words of the opening line of Junod’s Rogers’ profile, “Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?”: “Once upon a time, a little boy loved a stuffed animal whose name was Old Rabbit” (par. 1). Once upon a time, a staple of bedtime stories, recurs five times (pars.6, 15, 21, 34, and 45). That repetition not only emphasizes the children’s world that the subject inhabits—as the host of the long-running Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood—but also connects the once-upon-a-time anecdotes of Rogers’ life with those of some of the viewers whose lives have been profoundly affected by his television show, and by him. A case in point: The first once-upon-a-time sentence ends with “Old Rabbit” (par. 1). Because readers know from the article’s headnote that the subject is Fred Rogers, they assume that the opening anecdote about a young boy who throws his stuffed rabbit out of the car window is Rogers himself, but later—a quarter of the way through the article—readers learn that the little boy is actually Junod, who uses the once-upon-a-time trope to link his story, and others’, to Rogers’.
Another instance of Junod’s strategic repetition occurs in his locker-room description of Fred Rogers as he changes into swim trunks for his daily laps in the pool. Junod repeats the word slightly to emphasize how Rogers’ aging has altered many aspects of his appearance: “slightly wattled at the neck, slightly stooped at the shoulders, slightly sunken in the chest” (par. 5). The signs of Rogers’ aging are numerous, the repetition reminds readers, but the choice of slightly also stresses its limits. He has aged, yes, but he is still the young-at-heart host beloved by viewers. In Junod’s words, “[W]hen he speaks, it is in that voice, the famous one, the unmistakable one, the televised one, the voice dressed in sweater and sneakers . . . the sly voice that sounds adult to the ears of children and childish to the ears of adults” (par. 5).
In that description, Junod also describes Rogers as “white as an Easter Bunny” (par. 5), a simile that not only adds another element to the portrait of the aging Rogers, but also connects to the Old Rabbit of the opening line, to the return of Old Rabbit a quarter of the way into the story—where he is identified as Junod’s stuffed toy—and to a child whose encounter with Rogers appears midway through the profile, a little girl holding “a small stuffed animal, a sky-blue bunny” (par. 22).
That image of the child’s sky-blue rabbit also links to a detail about Rogers’ perceptions, one that Junod withholds for most of the profile. Near the end, Junod writes: “[H]e was born blind to color. He doesn’t know the color of his walls, and one day, when I caught him looking toward his painted skies [in his TV studio], I asked him to tell me what color they are, and he said, ‘I imagine they’re blue, Tom.’ Then he looked at me and smiled. ‘I imagine they’re blue’” (par. 37). I could go on, but those deceptively simple instances of repetition demonstrate the complex mosaics of Junod’s prose.
In a podcast interview marking the twentieth anniversary of 9/11, Junod told the PressBox’s host, Bryan Curtis, that writing “The Falling Man” was “a little bit like writing by Ouija board.” For readers who marvel at the quality of Junod’s writing, that simile applies to his other stories as well. Picture his hand on the board’s planchette, gliding mystically from the letters O-L-D-R-A-B-B-I-T to E-A-S-T-E-R-B-U-N-N-Y, to S-K-Y-B-L-U-E . . . .
The interview that reveals Junod’s Ouija-board image of his composing process is one of the six sources in the bibliography that follows. Two of the others are a couple of his most admired stories: “Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?”—the focus of the commentary you have just read—and “The Falling Man.” Rounding out the list are Hendrickson’s profile in the current issue of Esquire, an interview with a current student of mine, and a peer-reviewed article on Don DeLillo’s novel The Falling Man (2007), which references Junod’s article of the same name as a point of contrast.
That last source, written by a University of Buffalo professor, could serve as a starting point for a cultural or historical study of 9/11 writing. But as a teacher of freshman composition and a lifelong student of writing, I am interested primarily in Junod’s writing not for its treatment of 9/11, or any of his other subjects, but rather in how he renders them—with an artfulness that led his ESPN colleague Wright Thompson to call his oeuvre “the greatest collection of magazine stories that’s ever been assembled by one person” (qtd. in Hendrickson 29). Whether my continued study of Junod’s writing will lead me to pen a large-scale literary analysis of his prose, I do not know. Either way, the deeper understanding I have gained of his writing through the process of studying his words—and the commentary they’ve prompted—will inform my teaching, especially on those days when I hand my students the opening paragraphs of “The Falling Man.”
In “Don DeLillo’s Falling Man and the Age of Terror,” Joseph M. Conte probes novelist Don DeLillo’s fictional chronicle of the destruction of the Twin Towers and the scarred lives of a survivor, Keth Neudecker, a corporate lawyer who escapes the North Tower; and his estranged wife, Lianne, who was not at the World Trade Center but who is subsequently haunted by images of a Manhattan performance artist who dangles from bridges and buildings, imitating the posture of the Falling Man in Richard Drew’s now-iconic photograph. Conte explores the characters and landscape of DeLillo’s novel, as well as the challenges of rendering in fiction the virtually unspeakable events of 9/11.
Although the focus of Conte’s analysis is not Tom Junod’s own Falling Man, his study is pertinent to those researching Junod’s work, as it references his 2003 article “The Falling Man,” and demonstrates the contrast between DeLillo’s aims as a novelist and Junod’s as a journalist. While Junod aimed to depict photographer Richard Drew’s Falling Man as a human symbol of what the United States became on 9/11, DeLillo’s fictional Falling Man haunts the New Yorkers who witness him imitating the posture of the still-unidentified Falling Man in Drew’s photo. Notably, Conte cites Junod’s criticism of DeLillo’s The Falling Man in his June 2007 Esquire review of the novel, addressing his objections to DeLillo’s decision to write a 9/11 novel whose scope is not equal to that of the loss.
Joseph M. Conte, a professor of English at the University of Buffalo, is the author of Transnational Politics in the Post-9/11 Novel, Design and Debris: A Chaotics of PostmodernAmerican Fiction, and Unending Design: The Forms of Postmodern Poetry.
Hendrickson, John. “Family Secrets.” Esquire, March 2026, pp. 28-31.
As a prelude to the publication of Tom Junod’s new memoir, In the Days of My YouthIwas Told What it Means to be a Man, journalist John Hendrickson profiles Junod at his home outside Atlanta, where he asks the author about his relationship with his father, Lou (the focus of his memoir), as well some of his most well-known magazine stories, including the highly-praised feature on Fred Rogers and the much-maligned profile of Kevin Spacey. Hendrickson incorporates observations on Junod’s prose by a host of other writers and editors, includingmemoirist J. R. Moehringer; Peter Griffin, former deputy editor at Esquire; Taffy Brodesser-Akner, New York Times staff writer; Wright Thompson, Junod’s colleague at ESPN; and journalist Bronwen Dickey, who teaches Junod’s work at Duke University.
“Family Secrets” provides researchers with the personal history that informs Junod’s writing, especially his new memoir, which Hendrickson refers to as a book whose “concerns hum beneath almost every magazine story Tom has ever written” (29). Along with its vital background on Junod’s formative years, Hendrickson’s article offers the insights of other writers and editors who admire Junod’s prose.
John Hendrickson’s stories have appeared in The New York Times, New York magazine, Esquire, Rolling Stone, and The Atlantic, where he is a contributing writer. He is also the author of Life on Delay, a memoir about his lifelong struggle with stuttering.
“Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?” brings together Tom Junod’s conversations with Fred Rogers in New York City, where he met architect Maya Lin at her giant clock in Penn Station, to tape a segment for his TV show; in Pittsburgh, at his studio, where he produced Mr. Rogers’Neighborhood for thirty-one years and 865 episodes; and in Latrobe, Pennsylvania, where he navigated the perimeter of his childhood home on Weldon Street. Together, those conversations build the foundation for Junod’s profile of Fred Rogers, a portrait of a music major at a small Florida College who shelved his plans for divinity school when he first watched his parents’ new television. He detested what he saw—slapstick pie throwing—but, in Junod’s words, “[H]e believed, right then, that he was strong enough to enter into battle with that—that machine, that medium—and to wrestle with it until it yielded to him” (par. 32).
Junod draws on the repetition used both by and for children to chronicle the life of a man who dedicated himself to creating and sustaining an imaginary neighborhood where he and his Land of Make-Believe characters say the words that children need to hear. Junod’s profile offers vital background information for researchers examining the life and legacy of Fred Rogers and also serves as a primer for Junod’s signature style. Paired with “The Falling Man,” “Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?” showcases the patterns that are hallmarks of his prose, such as the metaphors and similes he crafts, which not only provide comparisons but also link the recurring images and ideas in his stories.
Tom Junod, a senior writer for ESPN, has also written for Life, Sports Illustrated, and GQ, where his articles garnered two National Magazine Awards. Among Junod’s other notable works are his Esquire feature “The Falling Man” and his newly published memoir In the Days of My Youth I was Told What it Means to be a Man.
Published in the September 2003 issue of Esquire, Tom Junod’s “The Falling Man” focuses on the now-iconic 9/11 image of an unidentified man in downward flight, who appears to bisect the Twin Towers. Junod chronicles the moments leading up to AP photographer Richard Drew capturing the photo, Toronto Globe and Mail reporter Peter Chaney’s search for the true identity of the Falling Man, the reactions to the picture—both those of the public and of grieving families (whose loved one could be its subject), and the photograph’s status as a national symbol.
Junod’s thorough and riveting account of Richard Drew’s photograph and its life beyond the frame illuminates the role of the Falling Man in American culture and highlights the writer’s award-winning prose. “The Falling Man” remains an essential reference for studies of the iconography of 9/11, as well as studies of Junod’s writing.
In his interview with Tom Junod, Bryan Curtis, editor-at-large of The Ringer and cohost of The Press Box podcast, talks with Junod on the occasion of 9/11’s then-upcoming twentieth anniversary. In his Q and A with Junod and the one with James B. Stewart that precedes it, Curtis asks the writers about their approaches to writing about 9/11, their writing processes, and the public’s reactions to their magazine features devoted to 9/11: Tom Junod’s on the unidentified Falling Man and James B. Stewart’s “The Real Heroes are Dead.” The latter, published in The New Yorker, focuses on Rick Rescorla, the decorated Vietnam War veteran and head of security for Morgan Stanley, who died in the South Tower’s collapse after leading an evacuation that saved hundreds from the same fate.
The September 2, 2021, episode of The Press Box podcast offers insights into the intricacies of writing about 9/11 and the writing processes of two journalists who reflected on the tragedy after the initial shock subsided: Stewart, six months later, and Junod, two years later. Their conversations with Bryan Curtis provide key first-person accounts for researchers studying the writing of Junod or Stewart in particular, or the journalism of 9/11 in general.
Welch, Sierra. Interview. Conducted by Jane Lucas. 23 March 2026.
English 1103 student Sierra Welch discusses first encountering Tom Junod’s writing when she read the opening paragraphs of “The Falling Man” in class and recognizing the distinctive qualities of his prose. In her words, “[H]e could have explained what he saw, but instead, he went into a description of one man, how he was falling, his pants, his legs, and used different similes to convey how significant 9//11 was and capture the emotional aspects for the readers.”
Welch’s remarks provide a detailed first-person account of a reader’s initial response to Junod’s prose. Her observations provide insights relevant to researchers examining general readers’ reactions to Junod’s words, as well as educators contemplating his writing as a subject of classroom study.
Sierra Welch is a criminal justice major at High Point University, currently enrolled in English 1103.
Up Next and Coming Soon
Tomorrow, Thursday, or Friday morning, you will complete your final essay and annotated bibliography. The due date for posting it to Blackboard and WordPress is Wednesday, April 8 (before class); the hard deadline is Friday, April 10 (before class).
In class tomorrow, you will compose an essay that reflects on the processes of researching, drafting, and revising your annotated bibliography and final essay. If you do not submit your essay and bibliography before class, refer to your work as ongoing. Carefully review the section of this post devoted to preparing, to ensure that you will be able to comply with all the assignment’s guidelines. Your reflection by itself will not be assigned a grade, but a reflective essay that doesn’t comply with the guidelines will lower the grade for your final essay and annotated bibliography.
To mark the beginning of Passover and the approach of Easter, today’s post features proper nouns in the Bible and the Torah, ones that are common nouns as well, making them playable in Scrabble. Some of these–including Gloria, Joseph, Maria, Noel, Ruth, Saul, and Veronica–-appeared in your first Scrabble post, “What’s in a Name,” along with your group pictures.
Bible: a definitive text
Calvary: a representation of the crucifixion
Gloria: a halo
Golgotha: a burial place
Jezebel: an evil woman
Joseph: a woman’s long cloak (after Joseph’s coat of many colors)
Judas: a peephole
Lazar: a beggar afflicted with a terrible disease, particularly a leper
Lucifer: a friction mark
Maria: a large plane on the surface of the moon that appears dark
Noel: a Christmas carol
Ruth: compassion
Saul: a soul
Sodom: a place infamous for vice
Torah: a law (pl. torahs, toroth, or torot)
Veronica: a handkerchief with a depiction of Christ’s face (after a biblical woman who offered Jesus a handkerchief to wipe his face as he carried the cross)
And Some Sweet Scores
Since Easter brings baskets of candy, here’s a list of playable sweets. If you have the right letters, don’t be a butterfingers.
Bonbon: a type of chocolate-coated sweet
Butterfingers: a clumsy person (also butterfingered but not butterfinger)
Candyfloss: cotton candy
Fireball: a ball of fire, a meteor
Jawbreaker: a type of hard candy
Jujube: a type of edible berry (not to be confused with juju: an object believed to have magical powers)
Nestle: to lie close to something or someone
Skittle: a form of bowling, or a pin played in that game (but not skittles)
Starburst: an image resembling a diffusion of light
Tootsie: a foot (also tootsy)
Updated Model Annotated Bibliography
The bibliography that follows, an updated version of the one I distributed yesterday in class, includes two notable changes:
The parenthetical citation at the conclusion of the summary of “Can You Say . . .’Hero’?” now includes the previously omitted paragraph number, which is thirty-two (par. 32).
The final paragraph of the annotation for the interview with Sierra Welch includes her new major, criminal justice. Also, I corrected the pronoun from he to she, but then eliminated the need for it by revising the subordinate clause, where she is currently enrolled in English 1103, to the more concise participle phrase, currently enrolled English 1103.
Remember that the model below does not include the paragraph indentations or the hanging idents you will include in the Microsoft Word file or PDF you submit to Blackboard.
Annotated Bibliography
Conte, Joseph M. “Don DeLillo’s The Falling Man and the Age of Terror.” Modern Fiction Studies, vol. 57, no. 3, 2011, pp. 559–83. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org.libproxy. highpoint.edu/stable/26287214.
In “Don DeLillo’s Falling Man and the Age of Terror,” Joseph M. Conte probes novelist Don DeLillo’s fictional chronicle of the destruction of the Twin Towers and the scarred lives of a survivor, Keth Neudecker, a corporate lawyer who escapes the North Tower; and his estranged wife, Lianne, who was not at the World Trade Center but who is subsequently haunted by images of a Manhattan performance artist who dangles from bridges and buildings, imitating the posture of the Falling Man in Richard Drew’s now-iconic photograph. Conte explores the characters and landscape of DeLillo’s novel, as well as the challenges of rendering in fiction the virtually unspeakable events of 9/11.
Although the focus of Conte’s analysis is not Tom Junod’s own Falling Man, his study is pertinent to those researching Junod’s work, as it references his 2003 article “The Falling Man,” and demonstrates the contrast between DeLillo’s aims as a novelist and Junod’s as a journalist. While Junod aimed to depict photographer Richard Drew’s Falling Man as a human symbol of what the United States became on 9/11, DeLillo’s fictional Falling Man haunts the New Yorkers who witness him imitating the posture of the still-unidentified Falling Man in Drew’s photo. Notably, Conte cites Junod criticism of DeLillo’s The Falling Man in his June 2007 Esquire review of the novel, addressing his objections to DeLillo’s decision to write a 9/11 novel whose scope is not equal to that of the loss.
Joseph M. Conte, a professor of English at the University of Buffalo, is the author of Transnational Politics in the Post-9/11 Novel, Design and Debris: A Chaotics of Postmodern American Fiction, and Unending Design: The Forms of Postmodern Poetry.
Hendrickson, John. “Family Secrets.” Esquire, March 2026, pp. 28-31.
As a prelude to the publication of Tom Junod’s new memoir, In the Days of My YouthI was Told What it Means to be a Man, journalist John Hendrickson profiles Junod at his home outside Atlanta, where he asks the author about his relationship with his father, Lou (the focus of his memoir), as well some of his most well-known magazine stories, including the highly-praised feature on Fred Rogers and the much-maligned profile of Kevin Spacey. Hendrickson incorporates observations on Junod’s prose by a host of other writers and editors, including memoirist J. R. Moehringer; Peter Griffin, former deputy editor at Esquire; Taffy Brodesser-Akner, New York Times staff writer; Wright Thompson, Junod’s colleague at ESPN; and journalist Bronwen Dickey, who teaches Junod’s work at Duke University.
“Family Secrets” provides researchers with the personal history that informs Junod’s writing, especially his new memoir, which Hendrickson refers to as a book whose “concerns hum beneath almost every magazine story Tom has ever written” (29). Along with its vital background on Junod’s formative years, Hendrickson’s article offers the insights of other writers and editors who admire Junod’s prose.
John Hendrickson’s stories have appeared in The New York Times, New York magazine, Esquire, Rolling Stone, and The Atlantic, where he is a contributing writer. He is also the author of Life on Delay, a memoir about his lifelong struggle with stuttering.
“Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?” brings together Tom Junod’s conversations with Fred Rogers in New York City, where he met architect Maya Lin at her giant clock in Penn Station, to tape a segment for his TV show; in Pittsburgh, at his studio, where produced Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood for thirty-one years and 865 episodes; and in Latrobe, Pennsylvania, where he navigated the perimeter of his childhood home on Weldon Street. Together, those conversations build the foundation for Junod’s profile of Fred Rogers, a portrait of a music major at a small Florida College who shelved his plans for divinity school when he first watched his parents’ new television. He detested what he saw—slapstick pie throwing—but, in Junod’s words, “[H]e believed, right then, that he was strong enough to enter into battle with that—that machine, that medium—and to wrestle with it until it yielded to him” (par. 32).
Junod draws on the repetition used both by and for children to chronicle the life of a man who dedicated himself to creating and sustaining an imaginary neighborhood where he and his Land of Make-Believe characters say the words that children need to hear. Junod’s profile offers vital background information for researchers examining the life and legacy of Fred Rogers and also serves as a primer for Junod’s signature style. Paired with “The Falling Man,” “Can You Say . . . ‘Hero’?” showcases the patterns that are hallmarks of his prose. For example, the metaphors and similes he crafts not only provide comparisons but also link the recurring images and ideas in his stories.
Tom Junod, a senior writer for ESPN, has also written for Life, Sports Illustrated, and GQ, where his articles garnered two National Magazine Awards. Among Junod’s other notable works are his Esquire feature “The Falling Man” and his newly published memoir In the Days of My Youth I was Told What it Means to be a Man.
Published in the September 2003 issue of Esquire, Tom Junod’s “The Falling Man” focuses on the now-iconic 9/11 image of an unidentified man in downward flight, who appears to bisect the Twin Towers. Junod chronicles the moments leading up to AP photographer Richard Drew capturing the photo, Toronto Globe and Mail reporter Peter Chaney’s search for the true identity of the Falling Man, the reactions to the picture—both those of the public and of grieving families (whose loved one could be its subject), and the photograph’s status as a national symbol.
Junod’s thorough and riveting account of Richard Drew’s photograph and its life beyond the frame illuminates the role of the Falling Man in American culture and highlights the writer’s award-winning prose. “The Falling Man” remains an essential reference for studies of the iconography of 9/11, as well as studies of Junod’s writing.
—. “James B. Stewart and Tom Junod on Writing about 9-11.” The Press Box, 2 Sept. 2021, https://podcasts.apple.com /us/podcast/ james-b-stewart-and-tom-junod-on-writing-about-9-11/id1058911614?i=1000534129966.
In his interview with Tom Junod, Bryan Curtis, editor-at-large of The Ringer and cohost of The Press Box podcast, talks with Junod on the occasion of 9/11’s then-upcoming twentieth anniversary. In his Q and A with Junod and the one with James B. Stewart that precedes it, Curtis asks the writers about their approaches to writing about 9/11, their writing processes, and the public’s reactions to their magazine features devoted to 9/11: Tom Junod’s on the unidentified Falling Man and James B. Stewart’s “The Real Heroes are Dead.” The latter, published in The New Yorker, focuses on Rick Rescorla, the decorated Vietnam War veteran and head of security for Morgan Stanley, who died in the South Tower’s collapse after leading an evacuation that saved hundreds from the same fate.
The September 2, 2021, episode of The Press Box podcast offers insights into the intricacies of writing about 9/11 and the writing processes of two journalists who reflected on the tragedy after the initial shock subsided: Stewart, six months later, and Junod, two years later. Their conversations with Bryan Curtis provide key first-person accounts for researchers studying the writing of Junod or Stewart in particular, or the journalism of 9/11 in general.
Welch, Sierra. Interview. Conducted by Jane Lucas. 23 March 2026.
English 1103 student Sierra Welch discusses first encountering Tom Junod’s writing when she read the opening paragraphs of “The Falling Man” in class and recognizing the distinctive qualities of his prose. In her words, “[H]e could have explained what he saw, but instead, he went into a description of one man, how he was falling, his pants, his legs, and used different similes to convey how significant 9//11 was and capture the emotional aspects for the readers.”
Welch’s remarks provide a detailed first-person account of a reader’s initial response to Junod’s prose. Her observations provide insights relevant to researchers examining general readers’ reactions to Junod’s words, as well as educators contemplating his writing as a subject of classroom study.
Sierra Welch is a criminal justice major at High Point University, currently enrolled in English 1103.
Coming Soon
Next week, you will complete your final essay and annotated bibliography. The due date for posting it to Blackboard and WordPress is Wednesday, April 8 (before class); the hard deadline is Friday, April 10 (before class).
Yesterday in class, I distributed copies of my Tom Junod bibliography in progress (and an updated version is included above). Early next week, I will post my complete final essay and bibliography to Blackboard and WordPress. In the meantime, look to my model essay and bibliography “Scrabble as a Game Changer in the College Classroom,” which I distributed copies of in class. An additional copy is posted in the sample papers folder on Blackboard.
Look to next Tuesday’s post as a guide for finalizing your revisions and preparing to write your in-class reflective essay on the process of researching, writing, and revising your essay and bibliography.